7 Top Commvault Alternatives to Explore

  • Archiving Solutions
  • Email Archiving
  • 7 Top Commvault Alternatives to Explore

    Best known for its backup and disaster recovery services, Commvault has expanded its product catalog into the realm of cloud management, migration services and email archiving. Commvault’s email archiving solution was designed with business continuity, information availability and regulatory compliance in mind, and offers a wide feature set, including custom retention policies, automated email collection and full content indexing.

    Commvault users have praised its email archiver for its reliable data storage and robust data restoration services — no surprise, given the company’s expertise in enterprise backup — but have noted that it’s challenging to configure and complicated to use, issues further compounded by the company’s alleged poor customer support.

    If you’re in the market for an email archiving solution but want to avoid some of the challenges associated with Commvault’s archiver, you’re in luck: We’ve compiled a list of Commvault alternatives to help kickstart your search.

    1. Proofpoint

    Built by cybersecurity professionals with compliance and eDiscovery in mind, Proofpoint’s Enterprise Archive is a cloud-based archiving solution that, in the company’s own words, “provides you with a secure and searchable central repository [for] a wide range of content types without the [headache] of managing an email archive in-house.” Enterprise Archive’s basic package offers SEC 17a-4-compliant capture and storage, unlimited self-service control for legal teams and more, and supports multiple file formats. For an additional cost, users can also access Intelligent Supervision, which provides total visibility across all forms of electronically stored information.


    • Great for compliance
    • Features DoubleBlind Key Architecture encryption


    • Immature eDiscovery toolset
    • Missing some basic functionalities
    • Monitoring and threat detection services need work


    2. TitanHQ

    TitanHQ’s cloud-based email archiving solution, ArcTitan, offers an expansive list of features, including enhanced Office 365 search and storage functionality, remote access to archived emails, email encryption and more. The company boasts 100% protection against data loss and savings of up to 75% on storage, making it a compelling Commvault alternative. ArcTitan earns high marks for its customer service and perpetual cloud storage though, based on customer reviews, small businesses might find the bar for entry high from a cost perspective.


    • Superb customer support
    • Perpetual cloud storage
    • Easy to implement


    • High price tag for small businesses
    • Dated UI
    • Overly simplistic search


    3. Intradyn

    Designed with innovation in mind, Intradyn’s all-in-one archiving solution captures and stores email, text and SMS messages and social media communications all in real- or near-real-time. With an extensive feature set, including custom retention policies, advanced reporting and analytics and robust search functionality, and three deployment models, Intradyn is ideal for organizations of any size in any industry. Best of all, Intradyn is constantly updating its products and services based on customer feedback and changes in the regulatory landscape, so customers can always be sure that they’re using the most advanced solution possible.


    • Top-notch customer support
    • Robust, intuitive search
    • All-in-one solution
    • IMAP/POP3 support


    • On the expensive side
    • Lacks built-in threat protection
    • Can take significant computing resources


    4. Jatheon Technologies

    According to its website, Jatheon’s “passion for data security, compliance and information governance drives us to create robust and flexible archiving solutions” — two, to be exact. Jatheon Archiving Suite, the company’s on-premises archiving solution, offers Exchange and Office 365 email archiving, 24/7 remote monitoring, custom policy rules and more. It’s also backed by Jatheon cCore and Jatheon Care — the company’s archiving appliance and customer service/maintenance plan, respectively. Jatheon Cloud, the company’s cloud-based solution, includes an even broader array of features, including enhanced search capabilities, PST and EML ingestion, advanced user management, free tech support and more.


    • Set it and forget it
    • Great customer support
    • Proactive monitoring


    • Confusing search logic
    • Dated UI
    • Slow search functionality


    5. Arcserve

    Arcserve UDP Archiving promises to help users “wave goodbye to the complexity of email archiving solutions.” Designed for single and multi-tenant architectures, Arcserve UDP Archiving aims to help organizations remain compliant with regulatory and legal requirements with its automated email retention and encryption, granular search functionality, easy-to-implement legal holds and more. With multiple deployment options and Single Instant Storage, Arcserve UDP Archiving provides flexibility and reduces archive storage, making it an exciting Commvault alternative.


    • Robust search
    • Integrates easily with Office 365
    • Single Instance Storage


    • Difficult to implement
    • Limited customer support
    • Does not offer stubbing


    6. Mimecast

    Best known for its email security solutions, Mimecast also offers email archiving in the form of its Enterprise Information Archiving solution. Mimecast Enterprise Information Archiving boasts an “industry-leading 7-second search,” remote archiving access, encrypted, cloud-based storage, and more. Mimecast has earned praise for its single, unified administrative console, its policy of creating triplicate copies of all incoming and outgoing emails for added disaster recovery and its robust spam filtering. That said, some users have reported that its spam filtering is so robust that it even blocks emails from known senders — an important detail to keep in mind when comparing Commvault competitors.


    • Robust spam filtering
    • Targeted Threat Protection
    • AES encryption


    • Poor customer support
    • Difficult to implement
    • Hidden costs


    7. SolarWinds MSP

    SolarWinds Mail Assure, SolarWinds MSP’s email archiving solution, combines archiving and cybersecurity in the interest of “[making] business email safe, available and resilient — even during an outage.” With off-site storage, automated email compression and geographic clustering, and inbound and outbound protection, Mail Assure is designed with 24/7 continuity and network protection in mind. In addition to security, Mail Assure offers long-term email storage with unlimited retention periods, compressed storage to reduce data usage and an advanced content and attachment-based search functionality, making it easy to quickly retrieve emails.


    • Excellent customer support
    • Robust spam filtering
    • Customizable dashboard


    • Slow to use
    • Cannot be accessed by multiple admins
    • Dashboard is difficult to navigate

    Whether you’re looking to make a switch or are shopping for an archiving solution for the very first time, it’s important that you weigh all of your options carefully — after all, the solution you choose will play a vital role in ensuring your organization’s regulatory compliance, in helping you to respond to eDiscovery requests and in handling litigation. Before making your final solution, be sure to take the time to thoroughly research and evaluate Commvault competitors.

    If you’d like to learn more about Intradyn, in particular, you’ve come to the right place. We offer a free, on-demand demo, so you can see Intradyn in action — and, if you like what you see, you can contact our customer service team to set up a free trial. Find out why Intradyn is the all-in-one archiving solution of choice for so many organizations and get started on your own archiving journey today!

    Avatar photo

    Azam is the president, chief technology officer and co-founder of Intradyn. He oversees global sales and marketing, new business development and is responsible for leading all aspects of the company’s product vision and technology department.

    Questions to Ask Before Buying an Archiving Solution
    Questions to Ask
    Before Buying an Archiving Solution
    Get My Copy